Puerto Rico‘s governor raised the island’s official death toll from Hurricane Maria from 64 to 2,975 on Tuesday after an independent study found that the number of people left to languish waiting for aid from the mainland that would never arrive, who succumbed in the desperate, sweltering months after the storm, had been severely undercounted.
CBS News obtained a report on the findings from Carlos Mercader, executive director of the Puerto Rico Federal Affairs Administration.
“The reality is that we take this very seriously,” Mercader said on CBSN. “We mourn those people that died because of this storm and we have a responsibility of making sure that we prepare Puerto Rico for a future event like this.”
To arrive at the 2,975 figure, the study looked at historical death patterns from 2010 to 2017 to estimate how many people would have died had Hurricane Maria not hit the island. That figure was then compared to the actual number of deaths from September 2017 through February 2018 — obtained in records provided by the Puerto Rico Vital Statistics Records division of the Puerto Rico Department of Health — to determine what the report describes as the “estimate of excess mortality due to the hurricane.
In May, a Harvard University study concluded that Maria wasfrom the day of the storm, September 20, until December 31, 2017 — a figure that was based on results of a door-to-door survey of 3,299 randomly selected homes across the island. Earlier this month, there were 1,427 more deaths “than normal” in the four months after Hurricane Maria and Hurricane Irma, which churned on a path just north of the island two weeks before Maria hit. That report, however, said those 1,427 deaths “may or may not be attributable to the hurricanes.”
The latest study says that from the period ranging from September to December 2017 alone, there were an excess of 2,098 deaths, and 2,975 from September 2017 through February 2018.
“2,975 — it’s 2,975 people who suffered,” Mercader said.
“We never anticipated a scenario of zero communication, zero energy, zero highway access,” Gov. Ricardo Rossello admitted to reporters. “I think the lesson is to anticipate the worst.”
He said he is creating a commission to study the hurricane response, and a registry of people vulnerable to the next hurricane, such as the elderly, the bedridden, and kidney dialysis patients.
“A lesson from this is that efforts for assistance and recovery need to focus as much as possible on lower-income areas, on people who are older, who are more vulnerable,” said Lynn Goldman, dean of the Milken institute.
Tuesday’s finding is almost twice the government’s previous estimate, included in a recent report to Congress, that there were 1,427 more deaths than normal in the three months after the storm.
By comparison, Hurricane Irma, the first Category 5 hurricane of 2017, which struck the Florida Keys and Northeastern Caribbean only 2 weeks prior to Maria, had directly caused 52 confirmed fatalities and indirectly caused 82 additional related deaths. Hurricane Harvey, a Category 4 hurricane which triggered intense, catastrophic flooding in the Houston metropolitan area in mid-August 2017, had caused at least 103 confirmed deaths, and was tied with Hurricane Katrina as the costliest tropical cyclone on record, inflicting $125 billion in damage. At least 1,833 people died as a result of Hurricane Katrina, which hit the U.S. Gulf Coast and caused devastating floods in New Orleans in August 2005.
The conspicuously high number of deaths in Puerto Rico has political implications for the Trump administration, which was accused of responding sluggishly and half-heartedly to the disaster, especially when compared to the federal mobilization of emergency relief to affected areas in Texas and Florida only weeks earlier. Shortly after the storm, when the official death toll stood at 16, a self-congratulatory President Donald Trump briefly visited the island to brag about the federal government’s unnecessarily limited and frequently delayed deployment of disaster aid relief he perceived to be a smashing success mission by marveled over the small loss of life compared to that of “a real catastrophe like Katrina.”
Rep. Nydia Velazquez, a New York Democrat, said the report shows the U.S. government failed the people of Puerto Rico.
“These numbers are only the latest to underscore that the federal response to the hurricanes was disastrously inadequate and, as a result, thousands of our fellow American citizens lost their lives,” she said in a statement.
There is no national standard for how to count disaster-related deaths. While the National Hurricane Center reports only direct deaths, such as those caused by flying debris or drowning, some local governments may include indirect deaths from such things as heart attacks and house fires.
Researchers with George Washington said they counted deaths over the span of six months—a much longer period than usual—because so many people were without power during that time.
“That caused a number of issues,” Goldman said, adding that people were forced to exert themselves physically or were exposed to intense heat without fans or air conditioning. “It’s fairly striking that you have so many households without electricity for so long. That’s unusual in the U.S. after a disaster.”
Puerto Rico’s government released data in June showing increases in several illnesses in 2017 that could have been linked to the storm: Cases of sepsis, a serious bloodstream infection usually caused by bacteria, rose from 708 in 2016 to 835 last year. Deaths from diabetes went from 3,151 to 3,250, and deaths from heart illnesses increased from 5,417 to 5,586.
Bethzaida Rosado said government and health care officials were not prepared for the storm, and she is still angry her 76-year-old mother died because oxygen tanks were not available on the island after the hurricane.
“Do you know what it’s like to see your mother run out of oxygen?” she said. “I don’t wish that on anyone.”
Months ago, the Rossello administration stopped updating its official death toll at 64 and ordered the independent investigation amid suspicions the dead were substantially undercounted.
The first phase of the study cost $305,000. In the second phase, the researchers plan to focus on the causes of death.
The researchers found that the risk of death was 45 percent higher for those living in impoverished communities, and that men older than 65 saw a continuous elevated risk of death.
They also reported that physicians and others told them that Puerto Rico’s government did not notify them about federal guidelines on how to document deaths related to a major disaster.
“Others expressed reluctance to relate deaths to hurricanes due to concern about the subjectivity of this determination and about liability,” the report said.
For the study, the researchers reviewed mortality data, including deaths by age, sex and municipality of residence, from July 2010 to February 2018. They also took into account an 8 percent drop in Puerto Rico’s population in the six months after the storm, when tens of thousands fled because of the damage.
However, they did not share details of the methodology, saying those will be released if the study is published in a scientific journal.
“We did not cherry-pick, I can promise you,” Goldman said. “We used very rigorous methodology.”
The study also found that government emergency plans in place when Maria hit were not designed for hurricanes greater than a Category 1. Maria was a Category 4 with 154 mph winds. Damage was estimated at more than $100 billion.
The researchers made several recommendations, including more emergency planning and government training for doctors on filling out death certificates.
They also said the public health system needs to be strengthened, though Goldman said they don’t know yet whether those weaknesses contributed to storm-related deaths.
She added that she has doubts whether Puerto Rico can adopt any of the recommendations. The island is trying to restructure a portion of its more than $70 billion public debt amid a 12-year recession.
“I don’t think they have the resources,” Goldman said. “That is a very critical issue.”
The report, “Ascertainment of the Estimated Excess Mortality from Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico,” is available here.